Thoughts? Lil Nas X Sparks Major Debate After His Viral Song Gets Bumped Off Billboard Country Chart
Thoughts? Lil Nas X Sparks Major Debate After His Viral Song Gets Bumped Off Billboard Country Chart

Source: David Becker / Getty

Disagreements on what counts as nation music has swept the music world because of the viral sensation Lil Nas X and his tune “Old Town Road.”

The tune combines banjo sounds with Nas X’s nation twang supply. However, all that is over a knocking entice beat.


According to Rolling Stone, Nas X launched the monitor in December and deliberately focused nation circles. Danny Kang, who co-manages one other viral nation sensation, Mason Ramsey, defined Nas X’s tune technique after Kang and his staff reached out to Nas X in December.

“On SoundCloud, he listed it as a rustic document,” Kang instructed Rolling Stone. “On iTunes, he listed it as a rustic document. He was going to those areas, gaining a little bit bit traction on their nation charts, and there’s a strategy to manipulate the algorithm to push your monitor to the highest. That’s favorable versus attempting to go to the rap format to compete with the most well-liked songs on this planet.”

Apparently, Nas X’s technique labored. “Old Town Road” debuted on Billboard‘s Hot Country Songs chart, the cross-genre Hot 100 chart AND the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. It additionally turned a success on TikTok, the app that lets customers create quick video clips set to music.

Despite the tune’s success, Billboard wasn’t feeling it’s placement on the nation chart. They eliminated “Old Town Road” from Hot Country Songs and instructed Nas X’s label, Columbia Records, that the tune’s inclusion on the rating was a mistake. An insider to the matter instructed Rolling Stone:

“Upon additional evaluate, it was decided that ‘Old Town Road’ by Lil Nas X doesn't presently benefit inclusion on Billboard‘s nation charts. When figuring out genres, just a few elements are examined, however at the start is musical composition. While ‘Old Town Road’ incorporates references to nation and cowboy imagery, it doesn't embrace sufficient parts in the present day’s nation music to chart in its present model.”

The insider went on to say that race had nothing to do with “Old Town Road” being knocked f the nation chart.

However, this may be exhausting to think about, contemplating Billboard has a historical past taking race into consideration when charting songs. For instance, Billboard‘s R&B chart was as soon as titled “race music,” whereas their Latin songs chart lumps a quantity genres and languages collectively into one ethnic umbrella.

Even nation radio hasn’t been too inviting to “Old Town Road.” The tune just lately hit radio, and in keeping with Rolling Stone, Radio Disney Country is the one nation station that performs the tune.

This brings to query the liberty songs to style bend earlier than they hit mainstream. While iTunes and Soundcloud may need allowed Nas X’s nation tags, it appears larger machines like Billboard and radio aren’t supporting it.

When race comes into the combo, it turns into ironic, contemplating many nation’s forefathers had been Black artists like DeFord Bailey and Lesley “Esley” Riddle.

If a tune has substantial guitar inclusion, storytelling themes and a rustic vocal supply, shouldn’t that be sufficient to get the nation tag…or are the entice beats an excessive amount of?

It brings to thoughts country-tinged hip hop songs like Nelly‘s “Ride With Me” and even Outkast‘s “Rosa Parks.” Neither tune hit the nation charts, however on reflection, would they do effectively in nation circles in the event that they didn’t must strictly undergo radio?


Even Young Thug introduced the nation feels just lately together with his tune “Family Don’t Matter” in 2017.


An argument could be made for having metrics for conventional nation music. But there additionally might be a possibility for music to achieve new audiences if songs weren’t restricted to 1 style. Country followers might witness Lil Nas X on the Hot Country Songs chart and open their horizon on the probabilities not simply nation music but in addition rap. It might make approach for a progressive sound that nation lovers can both take or go away, relying on their requirements.

Lil Nas X appeared to have this imaginative and prescient in thoughts with a tweet he made again in December…


He additionally gave the impression to be saddened by the information his tune being bumped from the Hot Country Songs chart…


Hit the following web page to seek out out what persons are saying about Nas X being faraway from the Billboard nation chart, and tell us what you suppose the genre-bending monitor!